It’s the form of story you’d count on on a Netflix crime documentary: a blackmail plot, a leaked intercourse video, a household deception and a world footballer who has gone from being the sufferer to the accused.
That participant is on the books of Nottingham Forest and at the moment in Spain with the remainder of head coach Nuno Espirito Santo’s squad, the place the Premier League membership are getting ready for a collection of pre-season fixtures.
Hwang Ui-jo, a South Korea worldwide with 62 caps, was charged by prosecutors in his homeland’s capital Seoul final week for allegedly filming sexual encounters with two girls with out permission on 4 events from June to September 2022. He has been dominated out of rivalry for choice by the South Korean nationwide group since final November and, if convicted, the offences carry as much as a most seven years in jail.
“The sufferer hopes the reality will prevail and that Hwang learns his lesson and realises how a lot harm his actions have brought on,” Lee Eun-eui, the lawyer representing one of many girls, has instructed The Athletic. “To be sincere, the sufferer is in such a state of disbelief and ache she will’t even articulate what she needs to see occur subsequent.”
Courtroom proceedings are scheduled to start subsequent month.
That, nonetheless, tells solely a part of a narrative that has already concerned one legal trial, culminating in certainly one of Hwang’s relations going to jail, and intensified a nationwide debate in South Korea in regards to the difficulty of “molka”, when movies are secretly filmed for sexual functions. Molka is an abbreviation of mollae-kamera, which means “sneaky digicam.”
Hwang celebrates a objective for Korea in November 2023, earlier than the nationwide group later dominated him unavailable for choice (Picture: JUNG YEON-JE/AFP through Getty Pictures)
Hwang, who denies breaking the legislation, is a former Korean footballer of the yr who performed in each recreation for his nation on the 2022 World Cup and has a world profession stretching again nearly a decade.
He signed for Forest in summer time 2022 from Bordeaux, following their relegation from France’s high flight, for £4million ($5.2m) however has spent the previous two seasons on mortgage at 4 different golf equipment, together with Norwich Metropolis of the Championship, English soccer’s second tier, and is but to make his official Forest debut.
The 31-year-old striker has been beneath intense scrutiny since June final yr when an Instagram account posted express clips from a intercourse video involving a girl who, it’s alleged, had no concept she was being filmed. The individual posting the pictures claimed to be certainly one of Hwang’s former lovers, and was accusing him of getting relationships with quite a few girls, of gaslighting them and secretly filming sexual encounters with out consent.
“A variety of girls have skilled an identical sample,” learn one publish. “He’s seeing celebrities, influencers and non-celebrities all on the similar time. I don’t know what number of victims there can be.”
Hwang’s administration firm, UJ Sports activities, described the allegations as “baseless rumours and sexual slurs” and introduced in legal professionals to take motion in opposition to the nameless account. However a special account was set as much as proceed the threats. In follow-up messages, Hwang was warned “there are numerous movies”, and that “it could be enjoyable” in the event that they had been launched.
“I’ve not finished something unlawful,” Hwang responded in a hand-written assertion launched through his legal professionals. “The publish (on Instagram) is baseless. I don’t know the one who shared that publish. She or he is a legal who has threatened me by defaming me and utilizing movies from my private life.”
When police began investigating, nonetheless, they uncovered a outstanding collection of clues that exposed the poster was not certainly one of Hwang’s ex-partners, in any case.
By monitoring down the perpetrator’s IP deal with, the police discovered the messages had been despatched to Hwang from his personal home. His sister-in-law, it transpired, was on the property on the time. She was there on the idea that she labored for Hwang as his private supervisor. And that was the second the investigation took a outstanding twist: every part had been despatched from her laptop computer.
The sister-in-law’s identify has by no means been launched, apart from her surname being Lee, but it surely has been reported in South Korea that she and her husband — Hwang’s older brother — had been administrators of UJ Sports activities, engaged on behalf of the footballer.
Hwang in pre-season motion for Forest in 2023. He’s at their pre-season camp this month (Picture: Bradley Collyer/PA Pictures through Getty Pictures)
In police interviews, she denied any wrongdoing and claimed she was being framed by somebody who had hacked her account. Over time, nonetheless, the proof started to construct up. Investigators had been suspicious when it turned out she had wiped her cellphone with a manufacturing facility reset after being known as in for questioning. She claimed it was to “shield personal info” on behalf of her brother-in-law.
Hwang, it was reported, had let her borrow certainly one of his previous telephones when she went on a visit to South America. That meant she had entry, probably, to his passwords and every part saved on his accounts.
The sister-in-law was charged with violating South Korea’s legal guidelines referring to intercourse crimes and committing blackmail. And, finally, she confessed to every part.
“I needed to show him a lesson, as he didn’t acknowledge the sacrifice that my husband and I’ve made for him,” she defined in a letter to the Seoul Central District Courtroom. “(We) gave up every part in Korea, moved overseas for Hwang’s success and taken care of him for 5 years. However my husband and Hwang had a disagreement final yr whereas Hwang was getting ready to return (to Forest after certainly one of his mortgage spells).
“I felt betrayed by Hwang for not acknowledging my husband’s arduous work. I felt extra betrayed as a result of I additionally left every part behind in Korea, giving up my dream and training to comply with my husband for Hwang, spending lonely days overseas.”
She was sentenced to a few years in jail (the prosecution had requested for 4) and instructed the courtroom her crimes stemmed from anger about Hwang “being ungrateful”. She apologised for her behaviour, describing herself as being “blindsided by revenge”, and mentioned she wished she may flip again time:
“Whereas managing his personal life, I got here throughout a video of Hwang having sexual activity with a girl. So I attempted to threaten Hwang so he would realise he trusted us (herself and her husband). The one intention was to show Hwang a lesson. I edited the video so the girl’s face wouldn’t be uncovered. I by no means considered ruining Hwang’s profession or harming the girl. I’ll obtain my punishment with out downplaying or hiding my crime … and stay with regret for the remainder of my life.”
The case has attracted appreciable publicity in South Korea given Hwang’s stardom and the added intrigue that he appeared at one level to take his sister-in-law’s facet, describing the investigation as a “misunderstanding”.
He has all the time been conscious, nonetheless, that on the similar time that investigation was launched final summer time, a separate police inquiry was underway into whether or not he had permission to movie his lover throughout intercourse.
Hwang returned to England final summer time for pre-season coaching with Forest earlier than becoming a member of Norwich on September 1, in what was presupposed to be a season-long association. As an alternative, the mortgage was lower quick in January after he managed solely three targets in 17 appearances and he spent the remainder of the marketing campaign with a membership in Turkey.
His greatest second in a Norwich shirt was a spectacular long-range objective in opposition to Watford on November 28. What few folks within the crowd would have identified was that, 10 days earlier, he had been questioned by police in Seoul for the primary time and his cell phone was seized as potential proof.
Hwang celebrates his spectacular objective for Norwich in opposition to Watford (Picture: Adam Davy/PA Pictures through Getty Pictures)
Three days after that, Hwang performed for his nation in a 3-0 win in opposition to China. Jurgen Klinsmann, a World Cup-winning striker with Germany in his taking part in days, was South Korea’s supervisor on the time and mentioned the claims in opposition to his participant had been merely “speculations”.
“It isn’t confirmed that he’s responsible and, till then, Hwang is our participant,” Klinsmann added.
Others had been much less impressed about Hwang’s involvement. The Civic Community for Justice in Sport, a marketing campaign group based mostly in Seoul, demanded an apology from the Korean Soccer Affiliation (KFA).
“(Hwang) should have self-reflection and willingly give up his place as a member of the group,” learn an announcement. “(The KFA) ought to have disqualified Hwang till the scenario is resolved.”
There was no apology, however the KFA introduced the next week that Hwang wouldn’t be out there for choice – ruling him out of the Asian Cup (Asia’s equal of the Euros or Copa America or Africa Cup of Nations) performed in January and February this yr – till “a transparent conclusion is reached on the info.”
[GOAL] 🇰🇷대한민국 5-0 🇹🇲투르크메니스탄
손흥민의 환상적인 탈압박 그리고 이어지는
황의조 뒷 발…ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
⠀⠀⠀#대한민국 #축구 #국가대표팀 #월드컵예선 pic.twitter.com/xQHTLirrGM— theKFA (@theKFA) June 5, 2021
Lee Younger-nam, who headed the KFA’s ethics committee, mentioned a participant for the nationwide group needed to “carry himself with a excessive stage of morality and duty”.
“A nationwide group participant should keep the honour of representing the nation,” the identical official added. “We took under consideration {that a} participant rigorously has to handle his private life. We additionally seemed into how this choice will have an effect on the remainder of the group and the way his presence on the sector would make our followers really feel.”
Within the midst of all this, a number of textual content messages had been disclosed to the Korean media displaying Hwang’s alleged conversations together with his former lover after the intercourse video was leaked on the web.
One of many lady’s messages, shared by her authorized group, learn: “I clearly mentioned no.” One other requested: “How come there’s a video after I mentioned no?”
Based on the leaked messages, she additionally wrote: “You’ll want to admit you dedicated an unlawful motion.”
Hwang is alleged to have replied: “I’m making an attempt to cease (this example) as a lot as I can.”
His authorized representatives say: “The video was filmed on Hwang’s cell phone and never taken illegally, as Hwang and the girl watched the video collectively after filming it.”
“The sufferer had no concept this video existed till it was in circulation,” the girl’s lawyer, Lee Eun-eui, instructed The Athletic. “The one motive why she even knew there was a video was as a result of Hwang contacted her within the technique of making an attempt to prosecute the one who had distributed it.
“The second she found this, she thought-about her life ruined and was in absolute despair. Hwang apologised and acknowledged the sufferer’s outrage however tried to elucidate that what he had finished was not technically unlawful. This declare itself will not be solely ridiculous but it surely makes one query Hwang’s idea of boundaries.”
Lee Eun-eui, pictured in 2018, says “the sufferer is in such a state of disbelief” (Picture: YELIM LEE/AFP through Getty Pictures)
An eight-month investigation led to Hwang being knowledgeable final week that he was being indicted for alleged breaches of South Korea’s Act on Particular Instances Regarding the Punishment of Sexual Crimes.
The Seoul Central District Prosecutors’ Workplace had additionally thought-about including secondary expenses in opposition to Hwang and his authorized representatives for allegedly revealing particulars that might establish the primary lady within the video however determined ultimately to not take it any additional.
“When the one who shared the video on-line was recognized as Hwang’s sister-in-law, Hwang had urged the sufferer to settle and cooperate,” mentioned Lee Eun-eui. “When the sufferer endured and refused to settle, Hwang and his authorized group determined to launch private information in regards to the sufferer, together with her marital and employment standing.
“The sufferer felt so threatened and scared she contemplated suicide. The sufferer continues to be in a state of shock, very distressed and uneasy about the complete ordeal. The very fact she nonetheless has no concept how Hwang was capable of receive the video is troubling, and the very fact it’s out within the open makes her very nervous. Not solely is that this hectic to the sufferer herself, however to her whole household as nicely.”
Lee Eun-eui has develop into a outstanding determine in Seoul since successful a lawsuit referring to the sexual harassment she skilled whereas working in gross sales for Samsung Electro-Mechanics, an organization so giant and highly effective in South Korea that the nation is sometimes called the “Republic of Samsung.” She constructed a brand new profession as a lawyer and have become a robust ally for the #MeToo motion serving to different South Korean girls with sex-abuse circumstances.
“There’s actually no method to take again what has occurred, and there aren’t any phrases to explain how a lot the sufferer has suffered,” she mentioned of the Hwang case. “I do know this can be an odd comparability however, if this was a case of rape, maybe the sufferer may heal over time, figuring out that it was a one-off occasion that she will work by means of to deliver some closure. Nevertheless, digital sexual abuse is a totally totally different story.
“If Hwang hadn’t secretly filmed and hidden this video for such a protracted time period, maybe this wouldn’t have develop into the scenario that it’s now, the place one thing so private has been broadly distributed on the internet, open for anybody to view and obtain. This isn’t one thing we will take again, ever. Even within the midst of all this, Hwang is making the sufferer out to be a liar and including insult to harm.”
Hwang performs in opposition to Portugal on the 2022 World Cup however his soccer future is now unsure (Picture: Ayman Aref/NurPhoto through Getty Pictures)
Hwang, whose profession started in his homeland at Seongnam FC and included two profitable years with Gamba Osaka in Japan, has declined to answer these feedback or make any assertion. His authorized representatives haven’t responded to an strategy from The Athletic.
As for Forest, every part has labored out in a approach they might by no means have imagined, on condition that the concept on the time of Hwang’s signing was that he would play for Olympiacos of Greece and never for them within the Premier League. The deal was organized through Forest as a result of each golf equipment are owned by the Greek billionaire Evangelos Marinakis.
Because it turned out, Hwang’s season-long mortgage to Olympiacos in 2022-23 was lower quick, resulting in a short-term mortgage association with FC Seoul within the January, and when he arrived in Nottingham for the primary time, his solely involvement for supervisor Steve Cooper’s group was as an unused substitute in two of their first three matches of final season. Nuno, appointed after Cooper was fired in December, had zero dealings with Hwang till just lately, when the participant reported for pre-season coaching.
Forest are conscious of the allegations however have determined at this stage to not take any motion of their very own. Hwang, in different phrases, stays out there for choice, even when it has all the time been the case that Forest’s intention was to maneuver him out this summer time. Even earlier than all this blew up, it was clear he had no actual future on the Metropolis Floor.
In the meanwhile, nonetheless, Forest are paying Hwang’s wage and have a participant on their books whose alleged offences threat laying aside many potential consumers.
In January, Hwang was made the topic of a journey ban stopping him from leaving South Korea. This, it was reported, was as a result of he had declined to be interviewed by the police on December 27, having already been spoken to a few occasions within the earlier six weeks. Hwang, it was reported, had complained that the questioning was extreme.
The journey ban was dropped 10 days later and the next week he joined Alanyaspor of Turkey’s top-flight Tremendous Lig on mortgage for the remainder of the season.
Forest are understanding what to do subsequent and, within the meantime, the legal professionals in Seoul are getting ready for a trial.
“Hwang is well known right here as a beloved footballer for the Korean nationwide group and, as such, I believe he’s getting particular therapy and leniency from all features of this course of,” says Lee Eun-eui. “The sufferer feels she is combating an uphill battle, however she actually hopes that justice can be served as a result of she believes within the fact.”
GO DEEPER
UK authorized reporting restrictions and why feedback are typically turned off
(Photographs: Getty Pictures; design: Dan Goldfarb)
