First off, no, your ANT+ units aren’t going to cease working. Actually, corporations are usually not solely supporting them going ahead, however will proceed to make ANT+ units for a while to return. As an alternative, ANT+ (or extra technically, Garmin), has introduced a coverage change that successfully and formally ceases the event of recent ANT+ requirements. Although virtually talking, that largely occurred way back.
The core purpose for this transformation is the European Union’s Radio Gear Directive (merely known as EU RED), which can finally take full impact subsequent summer season (it’s at the moment in a transitional section). That directive covers a flotilla of various areas, however one of the relevant items is that it requires authentication and encryption for wi-fi communications of private info. Or at least, it requires producers to make you conscious when information is being transmitted with out such protections.
Whereas ANT+ has lengthy supplied the flexibility to authenticate and encrypt information streams, it hasn’t been applied in widespread profiles like coronary heart charge or biking energy. Garmin says that to take action going ahead would successfully break backward compatibility because it considerably will increase the payload despatched in any message. Given the panorama of units and Bluetooth in 2025, there’s nearly no urge for food from different producers to re-create the wheel on the subject of ANT+.
Because of this, Garmin is making a bunch of modifications across the certification facet, growth, and program facet. None of those ANT+ modifications will impression customers in any method, anytime quickly. Nevertheless, there are another Garmin modifications that can quickly begin to impression customers.
Let’s dive into it – however first, it’s essential to grasp a tiny little bit of backstory right here, to see the long run challenges that lie forward.
A Little bit of Backstory:
No matter how you are feeling about ANT+ (or Garmin’s possession of it), it has remained as probably the most secure factor within the sports activities tech universe for nearly 20 years. I say ‘secure’, as a result of it pressured corporations to align to a normal, which made communications and interoperability seamless for units like coronary heart charge sensors and biking energy meters. There’s no query that biking energy meters wouldn’t have taken off if we have been nonetheless again within the days of proprietary SRM wi-fi, or wired PowerTap SL hubs. And definitely, because the Bluetooth energy meter profile has (and continues to) reveal – it’s removed from a dependable customary. In a assessment set for tomorrow, I’ll present how a preferred watch doesn’t appear to implement this decade-old Bluetooth energy meter customary appropriately.
After all, Bluetooth Low Vitality (the direct competitor to ANT+, versus full-blown Bluetooth used for audio that’s a distinct beast), rapidly gained reputation within the early 2010’s after the consortium introduced customary round health units, notably the guts charge strap first. Whereas corporations like Samsung and Sony had adopted ANT+ of their telephones, it was Apple’s determination to skip it that finally doomed ANT+. Actually, to this present day, the mere point out of ANT+ in entrance of Apple workers within the know, is akin to smearing poop on the lavatory stall (significantly). It needs to be famous, for funsies, that Fitbit really used to make use of ANT for communications between their early units and the preliminary wi-fi adapter on your pc.
It’d be remiss to put in writing an article about ANT+, with out mentioning Dynastream (primarily based in Cochrane, Alberta). That’s the unique firm behind ANT+, that Garmin acquired in 2006. The founding father of Dynastream would ultimately go on to discovered 4iiii in 2010, maker of energy meters and lots of different merchandise during the last 15 years. Nonetheless, regardless of Garmin’s possession of ANT+, it was by no means actually a significant downside for rivals. The (important) worth in having a standard interoperability customary far outweighed the very small licensing charge these corporations paid to Dynastream/Garmin. Customers noticed that worth, and gravitated in the direction of merchandise that had requirements in place.
The Tipping Level:
A key a part of any machine communication on both ANT+ or Bluetooth sensible are so-called sport/sensor/machine profiles.
Consider a sensor/machine profile as a approach to outline how sure forms of units talk. For instance, there’s a coronary heart charge machine profile for coronary heart charge sensors. Or the biking energy meter one, and so forth. Firms which have a stake in these profiles come collectively to try to create a single cohesive customary. For ANT+, there are dozens of those profiles. Some corporations like SRAM did an distinctive job of every new product they launched, they created an open profile for it (similar to Dropper Publish or ANT+ shifting). And Garmin largely did the identical as properly for every new product.
Within the case of ANT+, this course of was extremely regulated, and typically (okay, most instances) a wee bit sluggish. But when an organization had a imaginative and prescient for the profile and a particular product launch timeframe/date, it was usually fairly environment friendly. It grew to become much less environment friendly the extra corporations received concerned, or if the corporate didn’t have a particular product launch date. Stated otherwise: If you happen to danced your personal dance with function, you possibly can get a normal profile fairly darn rapidly. If you happen to concerned an enormous committee of rivals or have been wishy-washy on dates, it dragged on for years. One solely must see the much-requested Aero sensor profile as instance of that. And there are a lot of extra.
Nevertheless, the Bluetooth SIG facet had its personal points. These profiles have been coming scorching and heavy, however usually pushed by gamers that frankly didn’t have any enterprise being a part of that profile. We’d see automotive corporations concerned within the biking energy meter profile, for instance. Thus, that profile nonetheless suffers loads of issues to this present day because it doesn’t actually seize every part that energy meters did 10 years in the past, not to mention at present.
Nonetheless, by the mid-late 2010’s, many of the core sports activities profiles used have been obtainable in Bluetooth, together with Bluetooth footpods, Bluetooth energy meters, Bluetooth coronary heart charge sensors, Bluetooth Pace & Cadence sensors, and Bluetooth FTMS (for sensible coach management). Likewise, by that point, many of the chipsets used have been twin ANT+/Bluetooth Good. Virtually each sensor made since 2016ish has been twin ANT+/Bluetooth Good, albeit, it wasn’t till a couple of years later when multi-channel Bluetooth chipsets grew to become commonplace, making certain customers might connect with their coronary heart charge strap from a couple of machine directly (an issue primarily within the indoor coaching area).
Because of this, Bluetooth lastly grew to become not solely viable for sports activities usable, however simply as dependable in most situations. And in some instances, it dealt with wi-fi interference higher than ANT+ did.
How ANT+ Ends:
As I discussed earlier on, the only greatest dagger to ANT+ is the EU RED, and the necessity to encrypt information. All of this may require an enormous overhaul of ANT+, breaking backward compatibility with tens (if not lots of) of hundreds of thousands of units. Setting apart whether or not or not customers really need their reside coronary heart charge information on the health club encrypted, that’s the place we discover ourselves. Because of this, Garmin has introduced the next modifications:
– They’re discontinuing membership applications/charges: Up till now, there have been totally different membership tiers of ANT+ that corporations/startups might be a part of. These had charges, although comparatively minor. Nonetheless, Garmin says it wouldn’t be proper to cost corporations for a membership that doesn’t have long-term viability in it.
– They’re discontinuing certification applications: Firms might submit merchandise to be licensed as compliant with requirements. Some corporations like Wahoo took this fairly significantly, and despatched every part. As of March thirty first, ANT+ will cease accepting certification submissions. And as of June thirtieth, they’ll cease certifying new merchandise.
– They’re ceasing growth of recent ANT+ Profiles: No shock right here, there’s no new growth/growth of ANT+ profiles.
– They’re nevertheless persevering with to make sure ANT+ is offered on silicon: This ensures that ANT+ continues to be obtainable on chipset suppliers for a very long time to return. As one may anticipate, there are hundreds of thousands of units each from a sensor and show (e.g. watch/bike pc) standpoint that also wish to use ANT+ connections. Garmin says they’re working to make sure these chipset suppliers proceed to make twin ANT+/Bluetooth chipsets.
– All documentation to be made totally obtainable on-line: Sure tier ANT+ members might entry extra detailed documentation than decrease tiers. This mainly makes all ANT+ paperwork obtainable to everybody.
All of this mainly implies that your ANT+ units will proceed to work simply tremendous, and we’ll really in all probability proceed to see ANT+ units made by corporations like Garmin/Wahoo/and so on for fairly a while as properly. That’s as a result of there are workarounds to the EU RED necessities, similar to notifying the consumer. Or, merely assuming that parts of the EU RED will get delayed but once more.
Actually, we’re already seeing Garmin introduce some mitigations. In latest Garmin watch/bike pc beta firmware variations, you’ll see a brand new connection choice sort proven:
Extra on associated issues later/soonish.
As for the discount of ANT+ positions inside Garmin, the corporate famous that dropping their jobs, and that they “have a scarcity of individuals, not concepts”. Everybody within the Cochrane workplace is just being reassigned to different work areas. Garmin has largely leveraged the Cochrane workplace in recent times for tasks associated to sensors and different communication applied sciences (e.g. coronary heart charge sensors, energy meters, and so on…).
A Lot of Gaps:
Now going again to that preliminary pleasure interval within the 2010’s, standards-based profiles largely halted. Most corporations, together with Garmin, noticed the Bluetooth SIG as a hopeless entity extra involved with putting in roadblocks than progress. We noticed corporations like Polar and Wahoo – who used to have important pretense on the Bluetooth SIG’s (committee teams), considerably scale back involvement. Because of this, there’s been no new sports activities/health profiles in almost a decade.
Thus whereas it’s straightforward for a lot of customers to dismiss ANT+ as irrelevant, it’s very a lot nonetheless aside of sure scenes – the most important being biking. Issues get actually messy, actually fast.
Bought a biking radar (like a Varia Radar machine)? Yup, that’s nearly completely on ANT+. The one Bluetooth implementations are personal/proprietary implementations which are distinctive to every firm. Even radars from Bryton, Magene, and others all use ANT+ as the first protocol.
Bought wi-fi shifting or Di2? These too are on ANT. Within the case of SRAM/Campagnolo/FSA, that’s broadcasting your gear and battery standing on the ANT+ shifting protocol. Within the case of Shimano, that’s utilizing their proprietary ANT (however not ANT+) protocol. After all, that’s resulted in all types of messiness. However there may be completely *zero* Bluetooth different for any of those corporations proper now.
How about biking lights? If you need these biking lights linked to your Wahoo/Garmin/Hammerhead/COROS/no matter bike pc, that’s utilizing ANT+. Certain, there are, once more, proprietary Bluetooth implementations on the market. However they solely work inside that particular corporations ecosystem (considering of Lezyne for instance).
Certain, for coronary heart charge information the usual is properly understood on Bluetooth. It merely doesn’t matter whether or not or not you could have an ANT+ or Bluetooth Good coronary heart charge strap, they each work completely tremendous. There are minor execs & cons to every, however for 99.9% of customers, it simply doesn’t matter.
So what occurs to mitigate these gaps?
What Occurs Subsequent for Customers:
The reply to this part headline is easy: Again to walled gardens.
After all, that was already largely the development the final 4-5 years. Sadly, the COVID period additional cemented that by eliminating numerous interoperability conferences/occasions that had occurred prior. Including to that’s the heavy shift in the direction of startup tech corporations which have largely eschewed requirements as properly, be it protocol or file format.
Whereas one may assume Bluetooth SIG’s can be the reply going ahead, historical past and present firm commentary have very clearly indicated in any other case. I’ve but to discover a single sports activities tech firm that desires to cope with pushing ahead new machine profiles with the Bluetooth SIG. Firms don’t see that as a viable path to success, and definitely not price their time and complications.
As an alternative, corporations like Garmin say they’re going to work to make personal profiles extra obtainable. I requested Garmin for instance concerning the radar profile, which Garmin has had a personal Bluetooth implementation obtainable for years now. They offer that to some corporations upon request, to implement inside their apps. They didn’t have (but) a particular agency reply for a way that’ll look going ahead, however as an alternative pointed to Wahoo’s early launch a decade in the past of their coach management protocols for instance of the probably course.
For those who don’t keep in mind the early 2010 protocol days of Wahoo sensible trainers, they mainly created their very own coach management customary, after which revealed the API/SDK on a web site for all to make use of. That rapidly made Wahoo’s KICKR coach protocol the defacto customary for a interval earlier than the ANT+ FE-C customary got here into play.
Garmin has loads of historical past of doing variants of that, each inside the ANT+ sphere, but additionally their Join IQ developer applications. However whether or not they really achieve this is a distinct matter. Within the coach area, Garmin/Wahoo/Elite/Zwift all kinda quietly work collectively on numerous protocol issues, however they don’t usually attain the end line in a public method.
The sports activities tech business wants some substitute for what the ANT+ Symposium did for over a decade, each when it comes to an occasion to speak protocols (with rivals no much less), but additionally the backend course of to maintain corporations aligned to requirements for the opposite 51 weeks of the 12 months. Sadly, I don’t see how that occurs going ahead.
Till then, the excellent news is our ANT+ units will proceed to maintain working.
With that, thanks for studying!
FOUND THIS POST USEFUL? SUPPORT THE SITE!
Hopefully, you discovered this publish helpful. The web site can be a labor of affection, so please take into account turning into a DC RAINMAKER Supporter. This will get you an ad-free expertise, and entry to our (largely) bi-monthly behind-the-scenes video sequence of “Shed Talkin’”.
Assist DCRainMaker – Store on Amazon
In any other case, maybe think about using the under hyperlink if buying on Amazon. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. It doesn’t value you something additional, however your purchases assist help this web site loads. It might merely be shopping for bathroom paper, or this pizza oven we use and love.
