Probably the greatest Stanley Cup Playoffs in current reminiscence has now given technique to a history-making battle for the cup. The Edmonton Oilers and Florida Panthers will meet in a collection that may characteristic essentially the most journey in NHL historical past for a collection, with the 2 arenas being greater than 3,000 miles aside from Northwestern Canada to the Southeastern United States.
There’s no scarcity of unbelievable tales on this collection. An previous, proud hockey market vs. a brand new, renewed fanbase, two very totally different manufacturers of hockey, and the NHL’s greatest participant in Connor McDavid — a three-time MVP now attempting to hoist his first Stanley Cup.
If we minimize via the feelings of this collection and dive into the numbers we get a clearer image of who has the sting on this collection — and who ought to carry residence the cup ultimately, a minimum of in accordance with the analytics.
Scoring
It goes with out saying that that is the hallmark of the Oilers, and what introduced them up to now. Solely three groups within the NHL had the next Targets For (GF) this season, however the Oilers’ +57 differential was No. 2 within the west solely to the Dallas Stars, and even then simply barely.
No person within the NHL has higher middle play than Edmonton, who’ve a humiliation of riches throughout their three high traces in McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins. Mixed the trio put up a daft 91 targets and 214 assists for a complete of 305 pts this season, and that is each the group’s largest power and what this collection will hinge on.
If Edmonton is allowed to set the tone in scoring they’re very troublesome to catch. They recorded 765 high-danger scoring possibilities (HDF) in 2023-24, changing on 10.8 % of those possibilities, which was No. 2 within the NHL solely to the Vancouver Canucks.
In brief: The Oilers offense is ready to create mismatches with puck motion, and when that occurs they make their opponents pay higher than anybody else in hockey.
In the case of the Panthers their offensive recreation is much extra about grinding out the puck, getting gritty, and creating alternatives off their stellar forecheck. This group was solely eleventh within the NHL in scoring this season, nonetheless they love to regulate the puck in their very own zone.
This isn’t a prolific scoring group, however Florida swallow groups like a black gap and power them to play at their tempo. It’s because of this the Panthers had 56.2 Corsi score in 5-vs-5 conditions this yr, a measure of how a lot they had been controlling the puck in comparison with their opponents — in addition to a 55.3 % score in high-danger scoring conditions, which means they created extra alternatives than they allowed.
In the case of anticipated targets for (xGF%) vs. realized targets the Oilers are barely beneath tempo at -1.91%, which the Panthers out-performed their xGF by +2.75%, in accordance with Evolving Hockey.
If we isolate the scoring fully then the Oilers have an edge, however that comes with an enormous asterisk till we speak about …
Protection
It’s right here the place the Panthers actually come into their very own. As totally different as these groups are offensively, the disparity in protection is a chasm. In even-strength conditions it’s damn-near unattainable to attain in opposition to Florida, who solely allowed 119 targets in 5v5 throughout 82 video games this season.
Coach Paul Maurice has the Panthers operating an aggressive, efficient forecheck which takes super stress off his defenders. This has a knock-on impact the place he can rotate in deeper defensive traces, which retains his greatest skaters contemporary for situations that they’re really wanted. In the event you dig into the on-ice time of the Panthers high 4 defenders they lag WELL behind that of the Oilers, and but Florida allowed 0.48 fewer targets per recreation.
What this tells us is that basically Edmonton needed to work more durable on the defensive finish to a obtain a worse outcome, which is each an indication of the Panthers’ defensive depth — but in addition their capacity to not lean on their high defenders practically as a lot due to their forecheck.
Evander Kane of the Oilers leads each groups in hits by a ahead by a major margin with 250, however then it falls off shortly with solely McDavid recording greater than 100 hits by an Edmonton ahead. In the meantime, the Panthers have SEVEN forwards with over 100 hits this season, with Sam Reinhart recording a daft 66 blocked photographs this season in addition.
Florida isn’t a group that may fortunately skate again to their zone, reset and dare a group to enter their ice. As a substitute they prey on groups in their very own third, forcing turnovers, creating chaos, and scoring because of this.
Defensively the important thing statistic right here is predicted targets in opposition to vs. precise. Just like scoring, the Panthers have the sting right here. The Oilers are at a -0.16 (decrease is healthier on this stat), whereas Florida is a daft -0.49.
It goes with out saying that the Panthers dominate the defensive facet of the ledger.
Goaltending
Anecdotally the knee-jerk response is to imagine Sergei Bobrovsky of the Panthers owns this matchup — however it’s not practically as clearcut. Whereas Bob is actually the extra family identify between him and Stuart Skinner, the Oilers goalie really did tremendously effectively contemplating the circumstances he confronted this season.
Skinner had a complete of 35 high quality begins this season to Bobrovsky’s 37. He allowed solely .25 extra targets per recreation, and his goal-point share of 9.2 was really above league-average — regardless of the criticism the Oilers goalie will get.
If we issue within the high quality of protection in entrance of every of those guys there’s in all probability a good argument to be made that Skinner was higher than Bobrovsky this season. It’s a tenuous declare to make certain, however the actuality is that Bob hasn’t been unbelievable in 2023-24, however the group round him took off quite a lot of stress.
The difference-maker is that if these groups have to make a change. Past Skinner the Oilers don’t actually have an incredible possibility, with the growing older Jack Campbell and Calvin Pickard each having important consistency points. In the meantime Florida has Anthony Stolarz to take over when wanted, and whereas he’s not a night-in, night-out goaltender — he’s statistically superior to Bobrovsky this season.
Primarily in a head-to-head between starters it’s a push. If we issue within the depth then the Panthers edge out right here too.
Particular Groups
An extension of those groups’ offense and protection, it’s the facility play and penalty killing the place this collection will get actually enjoyable.
Energy Play
- Oilers: 64-for-243 (26.34%)
- Panthers: 63-for-268 (23.51%)
Oilers edge by +2.83%
Penalty Kill
- Oilers: 53-for-258 (79.46% killed)
- Panthers: 51-for-291 (82.47% killed)
Panthers edge by +3.01%
That is the thinnest of margins. We might actually break up hairs and say the Panthers are higher total, however it’s a stretch. Nonetheless, what we do see from that is that Florida open themselves as much as needing to kill penalties extra due to their aggressive play type. Florida allowed 44 extra energy play alternatives than league common this yr, whereas the Oilers solely allowed 11 greater than league common.
Total we’re speaking about very skinny margins right here total. The Panthers surrender possibilities, however shut them down. The Oilers take higher benefit of their alternatives.
Who wins the cup?
I’m a giant advocate of utilizing statistics to glean info, however there stays dozens of issues analytics can’t account for. The push-and-pull of a collection, particular person head-to-head matchups on the ice, the group, and on this collection how the journey will impact each groups.
That mentioned, all indicators level in direction of this being a yr the place the Florida Panthers will win the Stanley Cup Finals. Their aggressive forecheck and defensive chops have a much better alternative to throw the Oilers’ forwards off their recreation than vice-versa, and each matchup would require Edmonton to attempt to power early targets and stress the Panthers to chase them. That’s a tactic that hasn’t actually labored for anybody earlier than.
My prediction is a 4-2 collection win for the Panthers, and months of hand-wringing a couple of heat climate state taking residence hockey’s largest prize.
