5 NHL Draft winners and losers in 2024, starring the Canadiens, Geese, and extra

The 2024 NHL Draft is within the books and it’s persistently one of the tough drafts to attempt to parse. A mix of utmost youth, paired with multi-national scouting, the vast majority of the gamers chosen on Friday and Saturday received’t see the ice within the NHL for a couple of years — making it extra of an train in strengthening a pipeline, quite than construct a staff immediately.

Whereas it may be tough to judge lessons instantly following a draft, the perfect we are able to do is have a look at a category based mostly on how effectively every staff did with its draft capital — and based mostly on what scouting providers via of those picks previous to the occasion itself. To this finish we had some large winners in 2024, and a few absolute head-scratching picks.

Winner: San Jose Sharks

When you’ve gotten the No. 1 decide and get the perfect participant you’re going to be a winner by default, however there’s extra to what the Sharks did than simply Macklin Celebrini. This staff bought unbelievable worth up and down their draft board, bolstering their protection with Sam Dickinson and nabbing Igor Chernyshov with the No. 33 decide (he was seventeenth on my large board).

This was a forward-heavy class for the Sharks who’re in dire want of scoring. There’s a transparent method right here to rebuild the staff the precise approach, and we might very effectively be this class as a turning level for the franchise that lastly brings some tooth again to the shark tank.

Loser: Anaheim Geese

Issues weren’t so nice for the Sharks’ northern neighbors, and sure a whole lot of this has to do with taking Beckett Sennecke with the No. 3 general decide. It’s not that Sennecke is a nasty participant — in truth, he could possibly be fairly good. The problem is a whole misunderstanding of draft capital and the way to work the board.

A number of groups needed to maneuver up into the High 4 of this class the place the elite NHL-ready gamers had been. Not solely did the Geese handle to not take considered one of these prime guys, however additionally they didn’t transfer again and get something for it. While you shock everybody a lot that even your prime decide is shocked … effectively, it’s not an incredible signal.

Throughout their first three picks the Geese had been a -15 of their decide vs. consolidated rankings, that means they persistently took gamers sooner than unbiased scouting projected. Now, this might imply they had been proper and everybody else is incorrect — however that not often performs out effectively.

Winner: Montreal Canadiens

The most important benefactor of the Geese going off script had been the Canadiens, who bought an absolute steal at No. 5 in Ivan Demidov. The No. 1 wing on this class, it wouldn’t have been shocking to see him go at No. 2 if the Blackhawks elected to go offense over protection.

Montreal actually wanted to seek out star-power on this class, and so they did simply that with each Demidov and Michael Hage. The Canadiens would possibly want to attend a short time for Demidov to take the bounce, however he’s going to be definitely worth the weight. He’s been dominating the MHL as a real 18-year-old, ending with 60 factors in 30 video games. If this may proceed within the KHL we’re going to see a monster participant within the pipeline who can lastly flip this staff’s fortunes round.

Winner: Carolina Hurricanes

The Canes persistently discover a solution to be aggressive whereas additionally maintaining their cabinets stocked, and the 2024 NHL Draft was no completely different. Whereas this may undoubtedly be an offseason with a whole lot of change in Raleigh with Jake Guentzel set to signal with the Lightning, and Martin Necas being a wild card. Regardless of this the draft itself was an enormous boon for the primary take a look at for the organizations since GM Don Waddell left to hitch the Blue Jackets.

Regardless of shifting again within the draft a number of instances, the Hurricanes nonetheless managed to be a +24 of their first three picks — getting large worth of their alternatives vs. consolidated rankings. This was actually arrange by deciding on Nikita Artamonov with the No. 50 decide, regardless of being the twenty fifth greatest participant in rating and the No. 29 on my board.

There was very actual potential for Artamonov to be a High 15 decide, and the Canes have the posh to permit him to develop in Russia till it’s time to deliver him over. A do-everything ahead with authentic 2nd line potential, we might see him being a future star.

Loser: TRADE ALERT

Having the NHL Draft within the Las Vegas Sphere made for a few of the most unbelievable pictures within the historical past of the occasion. Sadly this additionally made for abject terror every time a commerce occurred throughout the draft and the Sphere had an enormous warning horn and the phrases “TRADE ALERT.”

It was sufficient to terrify everybody watching.

it was like aliens had been invading with each commerce. Please cease TRADE ALERT earlier than it’s too late.